Can someone challenge or contest a Will where they have been left out?
Wills may be challenged by interested parties on various grounds when someone passes away.
In Queensland, such formal challenges to wills generally take two distinct categories –challenges to the validity of a will on various grounds or challenges to the terms of a will.
Challenging the validity of a will
The first is challenging the validity of a Will where there is verifiable and credible evidence to support various arguments that the will was not properly authorised by the will maker or evidence which supports the conclusion that the will maker did not know and approve the contents of the will prior to signing it.
Wills may also be set aside or read down by a court if a matter proceeds all the way to trial in matters where it is found that adequate provision has not been made for an eligible person within the meaning given in Part IV of the Succession Act 1981 (Qld).
Wills may also be read down or gifts to beneficiaries may be altered or wills or certain provisions may also be held to be invalid by courts in situations where there is material and credible evidence to support allegations of undue influence, deception, fraud, mistake.
Wills can also be challenged on many other grounds involving some other form of duress or inequitable dealing or a failure to keep records evidencing that the person making the will knew and approved of its contents before signing it and confirmation that the person making the will had the requisite capacity to understand the nature and effects of the solemn power that a will maker must exercise when disposing of his estate.
A will might be declared invalid in certain circumstances for a number of different reasons, which could include:
- evidence that the person making the will did not have the mental capacity to understand the effect of what he or she was doing;
- evidence that the person making the will did not know and approve the contents of the Will or intend to confirm it;
- undue influence or pressure was exerted upon the will maker so that the will represents someone else’s wishes;
- the will was procured by fraud or false representations;
- the signature was forged.
Challenging the terms of a Will
The second type of common challenge to a will is best simply described as challenging the terms of a Will which is an action which may be brought pursuant to the relevant statutory provisions provided in Part IV of the Succession Act 1981 (Qld).
Family provision applications
At our family law firm, we regularly handle cases where eligible persons apply for further provision. We assist parties in resolving these matters in a timely and practical manner, as they relate to individual rights. In particular, we have extensive experience in efficiently resolving Family Provision Applications in Queensland. It’s worth noting that similar applications in other Australian States and Territories may be referred to as Further Provision Applications.
An ‘eligible person’ within the meaning given by Succession Act 1981 (Qld) refers to categories which are limited to include spouses, de facto spouses, children of the deceased and, in some circumstances, grandchildren and stepchildren of the deceased.
In contested Will claims, the Court considers a wide variety of matters and applies various tests in assessing what provision ought to have been made (if any) for those who have been excluded from benefiting from an estate.
An applicant must show that he or she is in financial need, but simply having a mortgage or dependants is often enough to satisfy that step. Some people may also have to show they were supported by and depended on the deceased person during his or her lifetime to establish grounds for a family provision application.
One of our Will dispute lawyers would be pleased to provide you with advice as to a potential claim that you may have or assist you in defending a claim.
The strength and weaknesses of various Family Provision Applications
Our will dispute lawyers understand what must be proved in relation to both of these areas and we have experience and up to date knowledge of the various thresholds which apply in each factual matrix.
Our wills and estate lawyers also understand that every situation is different. We take the time and care to understand your story, and to achieve the best outcome for you.
Sometimes that involves reaching a negotiated settlement which avoids the costs and inconveniences of a trial and may also include vigorously defending a challenge and pushing ahead to realise your full entitlement as a beneficiary.
Our law firm in Brisbane regularly advises and represents people who wish to challenge or contest a will on the basis of various equitable, statutory and/or common law doctrines and regularly act for various parties in applications for further provision made under the provisions of Part IV of the Succession Act 1981 (Qld).
We provide clients with sound and practical advice in relation to their prospects in successfully proving or defending an application for further provision and we often act in resolving settling various estate and trust disputes by way of a Deed of Family Arrangement or court orders.
Efficient, practical and cost-effective outcomes
At Seraphus Solicitors, we appreciate the commercial and common-sense benefits we are able to provide to our clients in quickly evaluating the strength of family provision applications and er are well versed in providing up to date advice and various solutions resolving dispute further delay or inconvenience.
This allows the people involved to move forward with their lives and facilitates the administration of the estate. We can work with you to negotiate a settlement, where possible.
We also act for staunch executors and trustees who are determined to uphold and defend the provisions set out in a person’s Last Will and Testament.
Strict time limits apply
If you wish to contest a will, it is extremely important that you are aware that time is of the essence.
It is vital that you seek independent legal advice as early as possible to avoid losing any statutory right you may have relating to challenging a person’s will.
Strict time limits will apply in all jurisdictions and any delay or failure to act by you in notifying a deceased estate that you wish to bring an application or any failure to bring an action after the expiry of certain time limits may result in the loss of an opportunity or legal right to pursue an action.
If you have any doubts about where you may stand in estate matters then call us to discuss what is on your mind.